Top Reasons Taxpayers End Up in Court and How to Avoid Them

Tax law is as complex as it is daunting. Each year, countless taxpayers find themselves entangled in disputes that lead to the tax court. Understanding the most litigated tax issues can empower you and your business to navigate the tax maze more effectively, ensuring compliance and avoiding unnecessary disputes with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). 

Here, we delve into the common areas of the tax code that frequently end up in tax court, offering insights and best practices to help you avoid IRS scrutiny. If you find yourself in a dispute with the IRS or another agency, remember that help is just a call away.

The Battlefield of Gross Income Disputes

Gross income, which encompasses unreported or underreported income, is at the top of the list of tax disputes. The IRS is keen to ensure that all income is accurately reported. Discrepancies often arise from misunderstandings about what constitutes taxable income or from simple oversight. 

Best Practice: Maintain meticulous records of all income sources and consult with a tax professional to ensure you report all income accurately.

The Dreaded Penalties: Filing and Payment Errors

Penalties for failing to file or pay taxes on time are also hotspots for litigation. These penalties can accumulate quickly, turning a small oversight into a significant financial burden.

Best Practice: Mark your calendar with all tax deadlines, and consider setting up electronic payments to ensure timely submissions. If you anticipate a delay, proactively communicate with the IRS to explore options such as payment plans.

The Quagmire of Itemized Deductions

Itemized deductions on Schedule A are another frequent subject of tax court cases. Taxpayers often struggle with understanding which expenses are deductible and the documentation required to support these deductions. 

Best Practice: Keep detailed records of all potential deductions and seek guidance on their eligibility. When in doubt, err on the side of caution and consult a tax advisor.

The Sole Proprietorship Conundrum

For business taxpayers, especially sole proprietors, income and expenses reported on Schedule C are scrutinized. The IRS closely examines these to ensure that personal expenses are not being improperly deducted as business expenses. 

Best Practice: Separate personal and business finances and record all business-related expenses. Regularly review IRS guidelines on deductible business expenses.

Innocent Spouse Relief: A Complex Escape Hatch

Taxpayers seeking innocent spouse relief navigate one of the more complex areas of tax law. This relief is sought when one spouse believes they should not be held responsible for a tax liability due to the actions of their spouse or ex-spouse. 

Best Practice: Understand the eligibility criteria for innocent spouse relief and communicate openly about tax matters with your spouse. Documentation is key, as is timely action if you believe you qualify for this relief.

Steering Clear of Tax Disputes

Navigating the tax landscape requires diligence, knowledge, and proactive leadership. As tax and accounting professionals, we advocate for a leadership approach emphasizing education, meticulous record-keeping, and proactive engagement with tax obligations. Cultivating a culture of compliance within your organization or personal finances can significantly reduce the risk of disputes.

We're Here to Help

Disputes with the IRS or other agencies can arise despite your best efforts. When they do, having experienced professionals by your side is crucial. Our team is equipped to guide you through the complexities of tax law, ensuring that your rights are protected and working towards a favorable resolution.

If you're facing a dispute or want to ensure you're on solid ground with your tax obligations, don't hesitate to call our office. Our experts are here to provide the support and guidance you need to navigate the tax maze confidently.

Share this article...

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .
I consent to receive SMS messages

Social Media


1 Presitge Dr Ste 212
Meriden, Connecticut 06450